Home » Neurosurgery » Neurosurgeon or Orthopedic Surgeon

Neurosurgeon or Orthopedic Surgeon: Making the Right Choice for Your Spine

When facing spine-related concerns, many patients find themselves at a crossroads: Should they seek a neurosurgeon consultation or approach an orthopedic surgeon? While both specialties have their merits, it’s essential to delve deeper into the specific training and outcomes associated with each to make an informed decision.

SCHEDULE APPOINTMENT

Advantages of Choosing the Right Spine Surgeon

Deciding between a neurosurgeon or an orthopedic surgeon is a critical step towards specialized care for your spine and nervous system. Each offers distinct benefits tailored to your unique health needs, ensuring expert, precise treatment.

Focused Specialization

Neurosurgeons bring an unparalleled depth of knowledge to neurological issues, offering precision in the treatment of the brain and spinal cord.

Musculoskeletal Mastery

Orthopedic surgeons excel in addressing the entire musculoskeletal system, providing comprehensive care for bone and joint health.

Collaborative Synergy

Choosing the right specialist often means collaborative care where both types of surgeons work together to provide a multifaceted approach to spinal health and recovery.

"*" indicates required fields

Training and Experience in Orthopedic and Neurosurgery

Neurosurgery and orthopedic surgery residents undergo rigorous training. However, there are substantial differences in the exposure each receives, particularly concerning spine surgeries:

Depth of Experience: According to a comprehensive 2021 study by Lad et al., titled “An ACGME-based comparison of neurosurgical and orthopedic resident training in adult spine surgery via a case volume and hours-based analysis,” neurosurgery residents log a notable 6.8 times as many spine cases as their orthopedic counterparts. This extends to hands-on experience as well, with neurosurgery residents recording 6.1 times as many spine procedure hours. This considerable difference implies that by the time a neurosurgeon completes their residency, they have had more extensive hands-on experience with spine cases.
Neurological Expertise: Another unique advantage of neurosurgeons lies in their comprehensive training in neurology. This foundation equips them with a profound understanding of nerve-related issues, making them exceptionally proficient at recognizing and addressing nerve complications.

Call today to schedule your consultation

949-388-7190

What Do Clinical Outcomes Say?

The training a surgeon receives undeniably impacts the outcomes of their procedures. This connection is evident in a 2022 study by Alomari et al., titled “Early Outcomes of Elective Anterior Cervical Diskectomy and Fusion for Degenerative Spine Disease Correlate With the Specialty of the Surgeon Performing the Procedure.” The findings indicated that patients treated by neurosurgeons experienced:

Shorter hospital stays.
Reduced risks of requiring a blood transfusion.
Lower incidence of sepsis.
Decreased likelihood of a return to the operating room.
A higher rate of discharge to their homes rather than rehabilitation or other facilities.

Testimonials

In September 2018, my ENT doctor sent me to see Dr. Taghva; as a result of the MRI taken after my ears were tested for possible hearing loss. It turned out that I had a brain tumor the size of a golf ball that needed to be removed; which most likely was the cause of some hearing loss. Both doctors thought it was benign, but due to its size I would need brain surgery to remove it. Needless to say, I was stunned and not really receptive to the idea. I never experienced headaches and was indeed in a bit of a shock. However, Dr. Taghva was very calm and patient with me and honest about the need…

5 stars
Jeannette P.

Dr. Alexander Taghva, MD, FAANS — Dr. Alexander Taghva – Board-Certified Neurosurgeon

Why Choose Dr. Alexander Taghva

Dr. Alexander Taghva is a leading board-certified neurosurgeon, specializing in brain surgery, endoscopic spine surgery, as well as spine disorders. Also, he is the only spine surgeon in Orange County and southern California who offers endoscopic laminotomy surgery. Dr. Taghva:

Graduated from John Hopkins University School of Medicine and completed his residency at the University of California
Completed a prestigious fellowship at The Ohio State University in Neuromodulation and Functional Neurosurgery
Specializes in minimally invasive and endoscopic surgery, spinal stenosis, artificial disc replacement, spinal disorders, spinal surgery revision, and other spinal conditions.
Specializes in brain surgery to treat trigeminal neuralgia, brain tumors, pituitary tumors, and Parkinson’s disease.
A highly-respected neurosurgeon with many years of experience, including treating chronic pain via stimulation of the spinal cord and brain
Actively involved in medical research and the lead investigator for clinical trials on spinal cord stimulation

In Conclusion: Which Type of Surgeon is Right for Me?

While both neurosurgeons and orthopedic surgeons are qualified to treat spine conditions, the depth of training and specific clinical outcomes associated with neurosurgeons make them a compelling choice for many patients. It’s essential to weigh these factors, along with personal preferences and individual health concerns, when deciding on the right specialist for your spine care.